Waterproof Maps - a Comparison

Most of us take a map when we go walking and we tend to assume they are clear and accurate. This review compares two maps covering the same area, both having the added advantage that they are waterproof.

Harvey Maps - Dark Peak including the Gritstone Edges

Less popular than the comparative Ordnance Survey series these maps offer quality 1:25000 mapping aimed specifically at walkers. At first glance the maps are colourful and easy to read. Look closer and you will discover a host of information that will help your navigation and awareness of the terrain. The following summary identifies the key features :-

  Waterproof paper with map packed in a plastic sleeve
  1:25000 scale
  Clear uncluttered style with enough detail for navigation
  More paths shown than on the OS equivalent
  Includes paths that are visible on the ground but are not right of ways
  Clear use of colour to show land use
  Very easy to read contouring
  Clear and easy to read typeface

Check out the full list of Harvey Maps

LAM-FOLD - Ordnance Survey - Explorer OL1 - Dark Peak Area

Based on the recently 'repackaged' Explorer (formerly Outdoor Leisure) Maps with an orange cover. They provide walkers with a valuable tool when out in the countryside.
Less widely available than their paper 'cousins', their key features are :-

  Conventional paper map in a sealed laminated protective film
  Tear resistant
  Write on wipe off surface
  1:25000 scale
  Standard Ordnance Survey details
  Easy to read style that we are all familiar with
  Some shortcomings with accuracy of paths
  Fully contoured with high level of detail

Check out how to order LAM-FOLD Maps

COMPARISON

Personal preference has a lot to do with which maps you use. A dedicated user of Ordnance Survey mapping for many years, I was surprised to discover how easy Harvey Maps are to use. At first glance they seem to be lacking in data but on closer inspection you soon discover they contain information that is relevant to walkers discarding much data that is not of use. They also benefit from detailing paths as being visible on the ground or not visible with the inclusion of many more paths especially in open country. In contrast the LAM-FOLD map is of very sturdy construction and will probably last longer if badly handled.

VERDICT

Harvey Maps        
- easy to read
- aimed specifically at walkers
- shorter life?

Lam-Fold / OS      
- very robust
- too much detail?
- bulky

Review date - 14th July 2002 - Reviewed by LJ